
Be it drowning family members or rescuing neighbors from pits of crap, China continues to not disappoint in the things that make you go “hmmm” department.
This time, let’s say that the son of a wealthy family killed an innocent bystander while drag racing on city streets and is up on a variety of charges, possibly resulting in the death penalty.
In an effort to protect their unfortunate son, the family asks you to be his substitute in prison. The sentence is guaranteed to be reduced to – oh, let’s say 3 years – and you’ll get paid for every day of it. What would you do? What would you charge?
This exercise in morality, justice, and finance has a longstanding tradition in China, where it’s called ding zui, or “substitute criminals,” but it largely went unnoticed in the country and was often regarded as an urban legend until the rise of the internet.
The above example was suggested by Chinese netizens determined to shed light on this alleged system of prisoner swapping. The photo above shows what certainly seem to be two different people, 20 year-old Hu Bin on the right enjoying his freedom, and “the Defendant Hu Bin” on the left awaiting sentencing.
That was in 2009, but recently, due to the high profile trial of Gu Kailai for the murder of Neil Heywood in which some believe a stand-in was used, the practice has been gaining international attention.
It seems that subbing in a convict is often done when wealthier members of Chinese society get caught with vehicular offences. One example reported by Chinese media cites that an unlicensed driver who killed a motorcyclist had paid someone $8,000 to do his time for him.
For a more clear idea on the market rates for this sort of thing: when a demolition company accidentally tore down the wrong building, the owner negotiated to pay a man $31 a day for each day he spent behind bars.
It’s said that the elites of China are in no rush to change this system since paying substitute criminals amounts to the same thing as imposing a financial penalty – justice and all that stuff can take a walk.
Although it totally undermines the entire justice system that society kind of relies on to function, some might argue that is helps to stimulate the economy by adding valuable jobs to the lower classes. It’s like a new kind of trickle-down economics: murder-down economics!
Source: Slate via Oddity Central (English)
[ Read in Japanese ]

The Sayama Incident: Kazuo Ishikawa’s half-century struggle against a wrongful murder conviction and Japan’s backward legal system
Female Korean Assembly Member Submits Bill Requiring Castration for Sex Offenders, Male Members Cross Legs and Go “Uuughhh”
Japanese Man Takes Customized Street Legal Porsche 962C for Sunday Drive, Goes to the Convenience Store
Japanese Man Recieved 1-Year Prison Sentence for Stealing 12 Cents
Life Imitates Art: Preteen Lolita Elopes With Stepfather
Our Japanese reporter freaks out after trying crappy Domino’s pizza in the US
Supermoon coming on June 23, lovers and lycanthropes alike hoping for clear skies
Osaka Obachan are here to rock your world, make sure you don’t go hungry
Mom makes authentic-looking Recon Corps uniform for baby daughter, Colossal Titan mask for herself
Correct short-sightedness without surgery: our reporter tries out orthokeratology
PlayStation 4 release date revealed?
Just Pop It In The Microwave and Charge! But Really, iPhone Owners should Know Better, Shouldn’t They?
Some McDonald’s customers in China are getting a little too close for comfort
Series of YouTube videos threaten attacks on commuters at Hakata Station on June 14
The avant-garde art of book stacking in stores of Japan
Chinese Photoshop Trolls Part 3: This Time It’s Personal
Chinese Photoshop Trolling Part 2: Now with 20% More Shirtless Men!
Ever wondered what Japanese prison food tastes like? Try it firsthand at the “Prison Cafeteria”
We Made Coca-Cola Transparent and Colorless. It Tastes Like…
Chinese Woman on Trial for Killing Man by Squeezing His Scrotum
A Chinese Perspective: Some of the Most Surprising Cultural Differences upon Coming to Japan
Chinese Motorists Undergoing Extreme Lucky Streak
Man Tries his Attempts at Evading Excess Luggage Charges at the Airport by Wearing Over 60 Layers of Clothing!
What do the Affluent Men of China Yearn for More than Anything Else?
Woman Despairs Over the Size of Her Son’s Penis, Drowns Him in the Bath
Chinese Morality Guidelines For Teachers Criticized For Not Being Relevant, Wouldn’t Be Read Even If They Were
Korean Man Develops Sex Offender Detector
Guilty and NEVER Proven Innocent – Every Male Train Rider’s Nightmare in Japan
【Heroism】 Younger Brother Catches Suicide Jump Sibling, Saves Life
What Will Come Out of the Mysterious Stargate in China?
Philip Kendall
Steven Simonitch
Master Blaster
Kay
Michelle Lynn Dinh
Jessica Ocheltree
Chinese Netizen Speaks Out: “China Spending As Much on Calming Civil Unrest As US on War Effort”
Leave a Reply